THE TROUBLE WITH GREEN
[Please subscribe to Eric Maisel: Thinking Aloud, which brings you a new “Tales of the Creative Life” every Tuesday and a new “The Craft of Coaching with Eric Maisel” every Thursday. You can subscribe for free here.]
Do you have trouble with green? Many artists do! The “problem of green” has come up for artists for centuries, and it has both practical and aesthetic roots:
- Pigment Problems (Historical Issue)
- Unstable pigments: Historically, green pigments were notoriously unstable. Verdigris (made from copper acetate) could corrode surfaces, darken, or even eat through paint layers. Other greens like malachite, terre verte, and Scheele’s Green had problems of fading or toxicity (Scheele’s contained arsenic).
- Difficulty in mixing: Unlike red, blue, or yellow, which can be mixed into a wide range of shades, green was harder to achieve reliably from mixing pigments. Getting a natural, stable, luminous green was a technical challenge until modern synthetic pigments (like viridian or phthalo green) appeared in the 19th–20th centuries.
- Symbolic and Cultural Associations
- Green has historically carried contradictory meanings—fertility and life on one hand, poison, envy, and even the devil on the other. This made artists cautious in how they deployed it, since it could overwhelm or mislead symbolically.
- In portraiture especially, green could look sickly or unnatural on skin tones, so artists often avoided using much of it in human subjects.
- Aesthetic Challenge
- Green is everywhere in nature (especially landscapes), which paradoxically makes it tricky: it can feel monotonous or overwhelming if not carefully modulated. Painters like Cézanne or Monet worked hard to break greens into many subtle hues (adding violet, blue, yellow, etc.) to avoid “dead” expanses of green.
- Many artists complain that green is either too aggressive or too bland—it doesn’t harmonize as easily as some colors unless adjusted.
- Modern Anecdote
- Picasso reportedly said, “They’ll sell you thousands of greens. Veronese green and emerald green and cadmium green and any sort of green you like, but that particular green, never.” His point was that the green of nature is elusive—no pigment quite captures it.
So, in short: artists consider green a problem because historically it was chemically unstable, symbolically tricky, aesthetically hard to manage, and elusive to capture in its natural richness.