Please enjoy the following fictionalized parable. And join me this coming week for a free webinar on the next generation of helping professional, the human experience specialist. Get registered for free here.
The beautiful failure
Nina painted alone. She entered the studio alone. She faced the canvas alone. She doubted herself alone. She succeeded or failed alone.
At fifty-three, after three decades of painting, Nina found herself restless. Her paintings sold occasionally. She had a modest reputation. A few collectors followed her work. Every so often she received a flattering review in a regional arts publication. It was enough. Or, rather, it had been enough. Now, it was no longer enough.
One afternoon she announced to her friend Rebecca, “I want to do something different. I want to create a giant community mural.”
Rebecca nearly spit out her coffee. “You hate committees,” she said.
“I do.”
“You dislike meetings.”
“Very much.”
“You complain about other artists.”
“Only constantly.”
“And you want a community mural?”
Nina nodded. “Exactly.”
She launched the project. The plan was nothing if not ambitious. Hundreds of local residents would contribute. Children, retirees, shopkeepers, students, immigrants, teachers—everyone would have a place in the design. The mural would celebrate the neighborhood and remain for generations.
That, at least, was the idea.
Reality arrived immediately.
Meetings went badly.
People argued about imagery.
People argued about politics.
People argued about colors.
One man objected to birds.
Another objected to the absence of birds.
Funding disappeared.
Volunteers quit.
A local blogger declared the project elitist. Another declared it populist—making “populist” sound like a curse word.
Nina spent eighteen months exhausted, frustrated, and increasingly convinced that she had made a terrible mistake.
When the mural was finally unveiled, it looked … fine. Not magnificent. Not terrible. Fine.
Some sections were beautiful. Others looked amateurish.
A few newspapers covered the event. The attention quickly faded. Within a year, several panels needed repair. Within three years, graffiti had appeared. Within five years, part of the wall had been demolished during a redevelopment project.
The mural was effectively gone. Nina regarded the whole undertaking as a disaster. Whenever anyone mentioned it, she winced.
“It nearly killed me,” she would say.
Years passed. Then, one Saturday morning, she attended a neighborhood festival. A woman approached her. “Excuse me,” the woman said. “You’re Nina, aren’t you?”
“Yes,” Nina replied.
“My daughter worked on your mural.”
Nina smiled politely. “That was a long time ago,” she said.
The woman nodded.
“My daughter was thirteen.”
“And now?”
“She’s an architect.” The woman hesitated. “She says that working on that mural changed her life.”
Before Nina could reply, another person approached.
Then another. A retired teacher. A former volunteer.
A man who had owned the bakery on the corner. A woman who remembered painting flowers with her granddaughter. They told stories. About friendships that had begun there. About belonging.
Driving home that evening, Nina found herself strangely quiet. By every artistic measure she knew, the mural had been a failure. But nothing she had ever done had entered the lives of others so deeply. Nina laughed. “What an annoying discovery,” she said aloud.
That night she slept well—for a few hours.